Each order is made from scratch and decorated entirely by hand. Pricing reflects not only ingredients, but also design time, skill, preparation, packaging, and communication. Custom cookies are both a dessert and a design service.
Yes. A minimum order of one dozen cookies applies for custom decorated cookies. For everyday treats, a minimum quantity applies depending on the option selected.
Minimums allow us to maintain quality and accommodate the time required for custom work.
Because every order is different. Final pricing depends on:
The prices listed on our menu are starting prices. You'll receive a clear quote before booking.
We recommend booking custom orders 2-4 weeks in advance, especially during peak seasons. Everyday treats require 3-5 days notice. Last-minute availability is not guaranteed.
To reserve your date, a 50% non-refundable deposit is required. The remaining balance is due prior to pickup or delivery. Orders are confirmed once the deposit has been received.
Minor adjustments may be accomodated depending on timing.
Significant design changes after approval may not be possible.
Absolutely. If you're unsure what option fits your occasion, group size, or budget, we're happy to recommend something that works best for you.
Yes.
Cookie cakes include a custom message and simple design.
Cookie cake bites can be lightly decorated and are ideal for offices and events.
Absolutely. Gluten-free, dairy-free, organic, and dye-free options can be requested for most orders. Please note that all products are made in a shared kitchen, so we cannot guarantee an allergen-free environment. An additional charge may apply for specialty ingredient substitutions.
Orders are prepared locally and pickup or delivery options are discussed during booking. Service areas and details will be confirmed with your order.
Clients choose Serotonin & Sugar for:
Copyright © 2026 Serotonin & Sugar - All Rights Reserved.
Serving Sarasota, Manatee, and surrounding areas.